Reverse Engineering

University Study Finds Rapidform Best Option for Parametric Solid Modeling from 3D Scans

21 Aug, 2011 By: Cadalyst Staff

A study funded by the U.S. Air Force concludes that INUS Technology's software is "the only viable option" for creating parametric CAD models from 3D scan data.


A recent study evaluating CAD and reverse-engineering software concluded that INUS Technology's Rapidform XOR is "the only viable option" for creating parametric CAD models from 3D scan data. The study was funded by the U.S. Air Force and conducted by Dr. Kuang-Hua Chang of the University of Oklahoma. The U.S. Air Force frequently needs to regenerate designs of decades-old parts, and therefore commissioned the University of Oklahoma to study both 3D scanning software and hardware to determine the best available technology.

INUS Technology had no knowledge of the study or its outcome until it was published in the journal CAD and Applications. INUS Technology reports that it invented the concept of creating parametric CAD models directly from 3D scans. The company introduced its Rapidform XOR software, which is used for reverse-engineering of physical parts, in 2006.

Chang and his students surveyed the software available for converting 3D scans into parametric solid models usable in CAD, evaluated the options, and tested the front-runners using practical examples. "We used five different examples in two rounds of testing," said Chang. "The first round was surface modeling, and in the second round, we focused on parametric solid building."

"We found that Rapidform is the only viable option that is able to support parametric modeling and transferring the solid model to CAD systems," Chang continued. "When we say 'viable option,' it's based on two things. One is the time and effort, the other is the accuracy." According to Chang, other software "was able to generate a parametric solid model, but it took a long time and the solid model created was not very accurate."

"It's very rewarding to see an unbiased study recognizing the value of Rapidform XOR compared to other 3D scanning software," noted Calvin Hur, INUS Technology's CEO. The entire paper, including technical details of each software program tested, is available for free download at http://www.rapidform.com/reverse-engineering-study.


About the Author: Cadalyst Staff

Cadalyst Staff

Add comment

Note: Comments are moderated and will appear live after approval by the site moderator.

AutoCAD Tips!

Lynn Allen

Autodesk Technical Evangelist Lynn Allen guides you through a different AutoCAD feature in every edition of her popular "Circles and Lines" tutorial series. For even more AutoCAD how-to, check out Lynn's quick tips in the Cadalyst Video Gallery. Subscribe to Cadalyst's Tips & Tricks Tuesdays free e-newsletter and we'll notify you every time a new video tip is available. All exclusively from Cadalyst!
Follow Lynn on Twitter Follow Lynn on Twitter


Latest News from Cadalyst Partners
Feed
AutoCAD WS is now AutoCAD 360   24 May, 2013

I wanted to share this blog post from Steve Bedder regarding AutoCAD WS/AutoCAD 360. This will be of interest to any WS...More>>Read more Without a Net blog posts>>

Feed
Load ‘Em Up! Stackers, Conveyors, and Advanced Assembly   23 May, 2013

Mineral resources come out of the ground and are then processed into energy, fertilizer, steel, and so on. We all kind of knew that already. But...More>>Read more PTC Creo blog posts>>

Feed
Excel Hyperlinks & Document Management Tricks   22 May, 2013

Do you have to keep track of a lot of different folders and files? Do you wish you peers could open the correct Revit file? Are you tired of having...More>>Read more BIMbuilder blog posts>>

Feed
Can spatial aptitude tests help predict your success as an engineer?   24 May, 2013

Do you enjoy taking these tests?  I know I...More>>Read more SolidWorks Blog posts>>

Feed
Sunglass.io Launches Library, Brings 400+ Suppliers to the Collaboration Platform   24 May, 2013

Here’s a quandry. How many supplier-certified parts and assemblies do you need to make your 3D viewing experience via the web worth it? What if...More>>Read more SolidSmack blog posts>>

Poll
What type of input device (besides the keyboard) do you use at your primary CAD workstation?
Standard mouse
Trackball mouse
Programmable mouse
3D navigation device
Pen/tablet
Multiple devices
Submit Vote




Considering Wide Format Printing Solutions?
Four FREE White Papers Available:






Subscribe Cadalyst Newsletters