Seven Pitfalls to Avoid as You Transition to 3D Modeling10 Jul, 2013 By: Robert Green
You've heard plenty about what to do when moving from 2D CAD to 3D and building information modeling. Now it's time to learn what not to do.
The transition from 2D CAD to 3D modeling and BIM (building information modeling) continues to change how we do business — and vexes CAD managers as it does so. But you already knew that. Whether you're implementing 3D systems in the form of BIM for architecture, mechanical design/simulation for physical systems, or 3D topology design in civil/GIS environments, you've no doubt heard many suggestions about how to make the transition.
In this edition of the CAD Manager's Newsletter, I'm going to put a new twist on 3D/BIM implementation by telling you what not to do. By sharing the mistakes I've seen made time and time again, I hope to spare you the pain of repeating them. Interested? Here goes.
Do Not Believe the Sales Pitch
If you read all the marketing materials for 3D software systems, you'd conclude that 3D/BIM software is so simple to use that no training is required at all. Buzzwords such as intuitive and easy abound in the literature, and it's easy to see why senior management staffs often fall for those claims.
I don't care what any marketing person says — you're radically changing the tools people use and the way they work, so going from 2D to 3D is not going to be intuitive, easy, or simple. In my experience the entire process is counterintuitive (as you unlearn the old software), difficult (change always is), and complex (because many standard work procedures have to change).
Rule of thumb: Use sales literature as a way to start the 3D/BIM conversation, but always question marketing claims.
Do Not Buy the 'Everybody Else Is Doing It' Argument
I remember completing my first 3D design and analysis project on SDRC Ideas software back in 1986, when AutoCAD was in its infancy. At that time, vendors in the 3D CAD industry (SDRC, Intergraph, ComputerVision, CALMA, etc.) said we'd all be using 3D software by 1995. Now it is 18 years after 1995 — and we're still not all using 3D. In fact, my surveys indicate that 40–45% of all CAD work today is done in 2D!
If 3D were that easy to adopt and use, we'd all be doing 100% 3D work every day. While some firms have made the leap to a totally 3D/BIM environment, most haven't. And of those companies that have attemped to switch over, many are struggling with the transition.
Rule of thumb: Your company should move to 3D methods only when it makes sense for you — not because of peer pressure or hype.
Do Not Underestimate the Time Required
If you heed my advice to question marketing claims, then you have to conclude that transitioning to BIM/3D isn't that simple. Therefore, you should take great pains to not underestimate the task or the time commitment. Over the years, as I've implemented all sorts of 3D software, I've found the following to be true:
- Transitions from 2D to 3D/BIM are measured in years, not weeks.
- Users are always more resistant to change than you expect.
- Production pressures always take precedence over learning new software.
- Any economic downturn will slow the rate of 3D adoption.
It seems that every time you get rolling on your 3D/BIM implementation, some factor in your workplace changes and the result is a slowdown/redirection of resources allocated to 3D implementation.
Rule of thumb: Figure out how long you think the transition will take, then multiply by at least 2, if not 3, to get a realistic time frame.
In her easy-to-follow, friendly style, long-time Cadalyst contributing editor and Autodesk Technical Evangelist Lynn Allen guides you through a new feature or time-saving trick in every episode of her popular AutoCAD video tips. Subscribe to the free Cadalyst Video Picks newsletter and we'll notify you every time a new video tip is published. All exclusively from Cadalyst!
Poll not yet available.