CAD Tech News (#115)20 Nov, 2019 By: Cadalyst Staff
Herrera on Hardware: The 'Creator PC' for CAD — Is There Really a Need?
An upgraded PC for visual creators is appearing on the market, but there's already a tool for that: the workstation.
By Alex Herrera
The modern PC has come a long way, and that statement holds whether you consider it in the context of reliability, performance, or the ability to scale to a range of price-to-performance points. It has carried a varied load on its shoulders over the years, from its beginnings running spreadsheets and text editors to today's incarnations that can arguably be called the most capable gaming machines on the planet.
Depending on your history, experiences, and perspective, high-demand visual computing (including CAD) has either been one of those areas where the PC has served its customer base well as the default go-to platform, or it's the most notable space where PCs have fallen short, requiring that professionals step up to the workstation — a machine that's evolved dramatically in terms of makeup, but always remained faithful to its ultimate mission of providing the premier platform for professionals.
Whichever camp you fall into, you'll want to pay attention to what's been going on in the computing markets lately: An undeniable push is emerging to market a PC that's not quite a workstation, yet promises a more capable platform for creators than a mainstream PC might. It's an idea that's still in the process of solidifying, but for the sake of discussion we'll call this new flavor of computing device the Creator PC, and you may come across it the next time you go shopping for a CAD machine.
PCs and Workstations: a Cooperative Partnership with Stubborn Historical Misconceptions
Let's step back, if you'll indulge me, for a bit of personal history that's particularly relevant. After studying electrical engineering with a focus on semiconductors and computer graphics, I started working in the late 1980s designing video and 3D graphics chips for workstations (at Digital Equipment Corp, if anyone can remember that name!). We created 3D graphics subsystems for — and only for — VAX and later, Alpha-based VMS (the OS) workstations. These were expensive, proprietary platforms intended primarily for use in the still-nascent CAD and media-creation markets. This combination of silicon, boards, and software was "only for" DEC workstations because at the time, all workstations were vendor-proprietary, and it was laughable to consider the PC appropriate for any kind of professional computing that demanded floating point computation and 2D raster graphics, let alone 3D (floating point is a necessity for 3D graphics). The mid-'80s PC still ran DOS, sported minimalist CPUs with no floating-point hardware at all, and the CGA-to-EGA-to-VGA progression was still in progress, just beginning to expose primitive bitmapped graphics to applications.
Clearly, the mid-'80s PC was a far more financially accessible machine (relative to workstations), but it couldn't handle much more than a spreadsheet or text editor. There was only one choice at the time for anything but the most minimalist CAD project, and to get it, users had to both cough up serious cash and tolerate living thereafter in a proprietary walled garden of computing options — built and marketed top-to-bottom individually by Sun, DEC, IBM, HP, SGI, and Intergraph, along with a few others.
In the late '80s and into the early '90s, that situation began to change. Sparked primarily by the advent of Windows 3.1 and the prospects of PC-based gaming, development of the PC base architecture and PC-based graphics hardware began to accelerate very rapidly. PCs and GPUs (though they were not yet referred to as such) pulled themselves up by the primitive bootstraps, and although they started well behind the workstation in terms of capabilities, they set a pace of innovation that the individual design houses at Sun and company couldn't match. It became clear by the early- to mid-'90s that the paradigm of the traditional proprietary workstation was doomed, as the PC ecosystem was delivering systems whose price-to-performance (and eventually, outright performance) was far superior to anything a vertically integrated vendor could offer. (To me, the emergence of Nvidia's Quadro — derived from its gaming graphics chips, but tuned to professional use — was the final death knell.)
By the mid-2000s, proprietary workstations were put out to pasture, and some vendors were out there grazing as well, either defunct or as shells of their former selves — including Sun, DEC, and SGI, along with the proprietary workstation development units at IBM and HP (and I went off to find work for PC-based vendors looking to 3D graphics opportunities in PC gaming). Over time, that old traditional proprietary workstation was completely displaced by a new breed, one that tapped into the same pool of CPU, GPU, memory, and storage technologies that the far larger PC market was able to deliver at an impressive economy of scale. Read more »
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Alex Herrera is a consultant focusing on high-performance graphics and workstations.
CAD Manager Column: Manage Major Changes with Incremental Innovation
In CAD management, the only thing that doesn't change ... is that things change! When coping with radical changes in software, hardware, or workflows, choose an approach that minimizes risk and cost. Read more »
PTC Prepares for 'Inevitable' Future of CAD by Purchasing Onshape, Part 2
How will the acquisition affect the market — and will it spell the end of Creo or Onshape? Read more »
Vusar Provides Augmented-Reality Viewing of CAD Models on Android, iOS Devices
The new AR app is designed to accelerate product development by helping creators and customers evaluate designs in real-world contexts. Read more »
Sponsored: CAD Data Exchange: How Easy Is It to Secure Your Intellectual Property?
From PROSTEP: Although it may seem easier to do things the way you've always done them, that's definitely not the safest or most secure way. Fortunately, CAD data exchange can be both easy and secure with the right integration platform. Read more »
AutoCAD Video Tips: Halloween Tricks for Scaring Your Fellow AutoCAD Users
'Tis the season for a little ghostly fun! Join AutoCAD tipster Lynn Allen as she shares some Halloween tricks for scaring your coworkers. Don't worry — you can always blame it on the AutoCAD ghost! Watch the video »
About the Author: Cadalyst Staff
For Mold Designers! Cadalyst has an area of our site focused on technologies and resources specific to the mold design professional. Sponsored by Siemens NX. Visit the Equipped Mold Designer here!
For Architects! Cadalyst has an area of our site focused on technologies and resources specific to the building design professional. Sponsored by HP. Visit the Equipped Architect here!