cadalyst
Management

Get the Big Picture

30 Jun, 2001 By: Michael Lennox

Four large-format scanners support color copying


For some CAD users, a large-format scanner is as indispensable as a printer or plotter. Traditionally, large-format scanners are used for archiving paper drawings—replacing those flat files with digital files. In GIS applications, large-format scanners are used to scan existing maps or aerial photographs. Those who use CAD for large-format design or CAM applications also use this technology. Though these industries include the heaviest users of large-format scanners, all CAD departments should consider the benefits of using them as part of a copy or scan-to-print system.

The players
Four companies provided scanners and software for review: Contex, IDEAL, Océ, and VIDAR. With respect to hardware, IDEAL, Océ, and Contex are all nearly identical. Outside of cosmetic variations, the differences are most apparent in the software—it is the key component to the entire scanning system.

Each scanner is an integral part of a larger system that includes the software used to capture, manipulate, and store the scanned image. These are key elements if you want to archive legacy drawings or use a scanned document in your CAD software. You can use scanned drawings in raster form, in which each element consists of small colored blocks called pixels, or you can convert them to vectors using raster-to-vector conversion software (see the CADALYST Labs review). None of the systems reviewed include raster-to-vector tools. They do provide copy software to support a scan-to-print system. If you have a large-format color printer, you already have the output end of a large-format color copier.

How we tested
We set up each scanner with its base options and tested each using the same Windows NT 4 Pentium III–based system with 128MB of RAM and an Adaptec 2940 UltraSCSI adapter. I scanned a D-size (22" X 34") map at 24 bits and 400dpi into each. Scanning speeds were affected by software and the amount of physical system RAM. Times don't include saving the file to disk. Some scanner manufacturers sell software or firmware-based upgrades to accelerate scanning times.

Reviewer's Report Card

 
Importance FactorQuality (X4)Speed (X3)Ease of use (X1)Star rating
Contex Chroma 8040AAB+5
IDEAL SuperWide 8050A AA5
Océ Color System 4050AAA5
VIDAR TruScan SurveyorAB+B+4.5 stars
 


About the Author: Michael Lennox


Cadalyst Fab Freebies 2021: The editors of Cadalyst, with help from our contributors and readers have updated everyone's favorite guide to software tools and resources that don't cost a cent. "Fabulous Freebies for CAD Users" has something for everyone. Download our guide today!


More News and Resources from Cadalyst Partners

Take the Gradual Path to BIMWhite Paper: Take the Gradual Path to BIM. Implementing building information modeling (BIM) can be a daunting challenge, but you don't have to take on everything at once. Learn how small, incremental advances can yield big benefits over time. Download your paper today!